Serious work is serious and playful work is...well, not! But some of the most serious research on games – like actual game design and mechanics, not gamification – suggests that playful work can be serious work, too. Play is how people experiment, stretch their skills, and build resilience.
We're going to dip our toes now into the impact of serious games and explore how exactly games can lead to learning, development, and change. These three facets help to illustrate why your team and their work could benefit from being playfully serious.
Learning
In a study of what makes digital games fun, Malone and Lepper (1987) found that curiosity, challenge, and fantasy are the parts that pulled people in. These three pieces create intrinsic motivation, meaning people play because the game itself is rewarding, not because of an outside reward.
For a successful serious game (or a game with work applications), the fun should come from the skill or the topic rather than only the fun elements of the game. This is what makes the difference between built-in fun VS tacked on fun, which is what we see in the case of the White House Arcade.
Malone, T. W., & Lepper, M. R. (1987). Making learning fun: A taxonomy of intrinsic motivations for learning. In R. E. Snow & M. J. Farr (Eds.), Aptitude, Learning, and Instruction, Vol. 3. Conative and affective process analyses (pp. 223-252)
Apply this to work
Any sort of game at work, including digital, benefits from making the skill or topic the center of fun. It's the fun that creates the buy in which leads to more enthusiasm, engagement, and energy for meetings, projects, learning, collaboration, and the sharing of ideas. Games are well suited when there's something to figure out, choices to make, or skills to practice.
Next time you plan an activity, ask: Would anyone want to do this outside of work? If the answer is no, lean into curious, challenging, and imaginative aspects that can turn a routine topic or brainstorm into something that provides an opportunity for fun.
Development
Let's say you get the choice between listening to a lecture as a group or working out your thoughts using LEGOs. The second option provides everyone with a chance to think individually from different angles, visualize thoughts, and try things out instead of immediately jumping into answers.
In our LEGO example, we're making space to play and explore. Play is how people naturally experiment and push the boundaries of their comfort zone. While play is typically more involved or challenging than what we're used to at work, folks are often drawn to the more challenging activities, when they're voluntary (Rieber 1996).
Rieber, L. P. (1996). Seriously considering play: Designing interactive learning environments based on the blending of microworlds, simulations, and games. Educational Technology Research and Development.
Apply this to work
Make opportunities to play. Look to make participating optional, and add more ways to participate – like player, observer, note taker, scorekeeper, etc.
Change
Do you remember the first time you played rock, paper, scissors? For me, I remember struggling to grasp the finer points because the older kids would crush me and the adults took it too easy on me. It wasn't until I played with kids my age who could teach it just right that I could then become competitive (it's a game of luck AND skill).
Vygotsky called this the "zone of proximal development." Basically, the goldilocks principle of learning – it has to be just challenging enough that you can figure it out on your own but not so hard that it becomes overwhelming. The challenge maintains interest while the ability to overcome it builds confidence that you can overcome another challenge.
Vygotsky, L. S. (1978). Mind in Society: The Development of Higher Psychological Processes.
Apply this to work
At work, we see a variety of skill levels in individuals, but rarely do we see that a training, workshop, or even meeting reflect and engage people on their own level. Consider cybersecurity training. For the experienced, it's such a chore that new info can be missed, and for the beginners, it can be nerve racking to get things wrong again and again in a lesson pop quiz.
Teams are also mixed like this. What type of game or activity won't bore experienced people or overwhelm beginners? It's an interesting design question for sure, but play is perfect for creating levels of challenge. Build support from the experienced players in, but also don't be afraid to make things difficult. Somewhere in there is that goldilocks zone for each member of your team.
Start small
Play is a powerful tool. Think about an upcoming brainstorm for work, a stand-up, or other work activity that you do on the regular. Change one of the following and see how it goes.
- Is it fun? If no, how can you make the fun come from that topic or skill?
- Is there room to play? If no, how can I create some?
- Is the challenge just right? How does it work for experienced people, beginners, and folks in between?